The Collapse of the National Consultative Council (NCC) in Somalia is a critical reflection of the ongoing Political crisis..

The collapse of the National Consultative Council (NCC) in Somalia is a critical reflection of the ongoing political crisis, with significant responsibility resting on the leadership of President Hassan Sheikh and Prime Minister Hamza Abdi Barre. Here’s an
analysis of the current situation:
President Leadership Challenges…

1. Disconnection from Ground Realities: President Mohamoud is increasingly perceived as disconnected from the realities faced by various regions in Somalia. His policies often
   fail to resonate with local needs, leading to growing frustration among regional leaders.
2. Dismantling Federalism: There are serious concerns about the president’s efforts to dismantle and alter the federal constitution and system. This undermines the autonomy of
   regional states, particularly Puntland and Jubaland, leading to heightened tensions.
3. Concentration of Power: The president’s consolidation of roles—as often referred to as the “3 in 1” (President, Prime Minister, and Speaker of Parliament)—has raised alarms
   about the erosion of democratic processes and the marginalization of other political leaders.

Prime Minister Hamza Abdi Barre’s Ineffectiveness:

• Lack of Leadership and Experience: Prime Minister Barre has faced criticism for his inability to lead effectively. His government’s failure to engage with regional states and address their concerns has contributed to the crisis and ultimately the collapse of the
  NCC.
  Key Factors Leading to NCC Collapse
  Absence of Puntland State
• Critical Stakeholder: Puntland’s absence from the NCC severely weakened the council’s
  legitimacy. As a key regional player, its exclusion hindered meaningful discussions on national governance and unity.
  Jubaland State’s Refusal
• Ahmed Madobe’s Walkout: Jubaland President Ahmed Madobe’s decision to walk out of the NCC meeting was significant. He argued against:
• One-Year Extension: Refusing any extension of Jubaland’s electoral timeline, insisting
  on conducting elections on time through the Jubaland electoral commission without
  federal interference.
• Need for Inclusion: Madobe repeatedly emphasized that discussions on national issues could not proceed without the participation of Puntland and the SSC, which further
  complicated the dialogue.
  Exclusion of the SSC Administration
• Lack of Invitation: The SSC’s exclusion from the NCC reflects broader issues of
  representation and recognition within Somalia’s political framework. This absence limits
  meaningful dialogue and exacerbates regional tensions.
  Urgent Need for Change

1. Call for New Leadership: There is an urgent need for a change in leadership, particularly in the role of Prime Minister. Many believe that a new Prime Minister could help form a more effective government that better addresses the concerns of all regions.
2. Face-Saving Measures:
   For President Mohamoud to regain credibility, he must take genuine steps toward inclusivity and collaboration with regional leaders. This could involve reshaping his government and acknowledging the need for a more balanced federal structure.
   Conclusion

The collapse of the National Consultative Council highlights the complexities and
challenges within Somalia’s political landscape. President Hassan Sheikh Mohamoud’s disconnection from regional realities and concentration of power, alongside Prime Minister Hamza Abdi Barre’s ineffective leadership, have contributed significantly to the current
crisis. To move forward, it is essential to foster an inclusive political environment that incorporates all stakeholders—particularly Puntland, Jubaland, and the SSC—into the dialogue. A change in leadership may be necessary to restore faith in the government and pave the way for effective governance in Somalia.